Search Results
Search this site
243 results found with an empty search
- December Lights
In December both Christians and Jews hold candle-lighting rituals. Christian families light the Advent wreath candles on the Sundays leading to Christmas, while Jewish families light a candle for each of the eight days of Hanukkah . This year, 2024, in a rare calendar event, the commencement of Hanukkah coincides with Christmas night on 25 December. Can this coincidence of the Christian and Jewish liturgical cycles point us towards a deeper unity as Christians and Jews? One very practical suggestion offered at an Australian gathering of Christians and Jews, is that Christian homes light a candle and place it in the window on Christmas night, as Jewish homes begin their Hanukkah festivities. This would be a visible and public symbol of Christian solidarity with the Jewish community; a shared commitment to unity, hope and light in the face of the darkness of antisemitism. Let’s delve further into the custom of candle-lighting. Christians are familiar with Advent and Christmas candles. But why do Jews light candles at Hanukkah? Hanukkah means ‘dedication.’ This festival takes us back to the 2nd century BCE and recalls the re-dedication of the Jerusalem temple following the Maccabean uprising. The books of 1 & 2 Maccabees tell this story as the persecution of the Jewish population: forced conversions, brutal punishments, and defilement of the temple as a powerful Greek Hellenistic culture threatened to suppress Judaism. The text includes the gripping tales of Maccabean resistance and heroic martyrs, such as a Jewish mother and her seven sons who accepted torture and death rather than renounce the religious practices of their ancestors (2 Maccabees 7). According to rabbinic tradition, when the Maccabeans reclaimed the temple and lit the temple menorah (lamp stand), a miracle occurred: amidst the ruins they could find only a small quantity of pure oil, enough for one day of light, yet the menorah stayed alight for eight days. In the miracle of the cruse of oil, commentators note the courage of the Jews to attempt to light the menorah in the first place. Why bother when it seemed that the oil would not last beyond a day? The act of lamp-lighting indicates resilient hope and persistent faith. In Hanukkah there is much to inspire Christians. Christians might ponder the idea that were it not for the reality that Hanukkah represents, had not the Jewish people prevailed time and again in history in the face of forces bent on their destruction, there would be no Jewish communities to carry on the traditions of their faith, to be a light to the nations. There would be no child Jesus born and raised in the teachings of the Torah. There would be no Christmas. The nearness of a Jewish festival to Christmas can remind Christians that the little family in Bethlehem 2,000 years ago were faithful Jews who celebrated the festivals of their tradition according to the customs of their day. Each in its unique way, Advent and Hanukkah engender a spirit of renewal. Remembering the re-dedication of the ancient temple, Jews today approach Hanukkah as a time for spiritual re-dedication of their lives. Meanwhile, Christians prepare their hearts to celebrate Christmas in accordance with their own sacred traditions. For Catholics, Jewish-Christian reconciliation was a key teaching at the Second Vatican Council, a teaching taken up by other mainstream Churches too. The coinciding dates of Hanukkah and Christmas candle-lighting customs in the respective calendars of two different religious traditions affords an opportunity for Christians to show solidarity with Jewish friends, as the first Hanukkah candle is lit on the evening of 25 December 2024. Together, may we spread light and hope and be a blessing for the world. © Teresa Pirola, 2021, 2024. lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry based in the Catholic community in Australia, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights.
- Jacob's Struggle
“Your name shall no longer be Jacob, but Israel, for you have striven with beings divine and human, and have prevailed” (Genesis 32:29). In the book of Genesis we find the story of Jacob’s wrestling match with a mysterious man. This is a minefield of symbols to be interpreted humanly and religiously. To comprehend the text we need to view it in the context of the story of Jacob’s reunion with his brother Esau. Jacob, together with his household, is heading home after a twenty year sojourn outside the land of Canaan. Along the way he learns that his brother Esau, together with 400 men, is coming to meet him. Fearful that Esau still harbours murderous rage over a long-ago conflict, Jacob prepares for the worst (Gen. 32:4-22). The night before the two brothers meet, Jacob wrestles with a mysterious figure, thought to be a divine representative (Gen. 32:23-33). And what happens the next day? “Esau ran to greet him. He embraced him...he kissed him; and they wept” (Genesis 33:4). Esau’s reaction is startling. Last time they were together Esau was out to kill Jacob. Now he shows nothing but love toward his brother who deceived him all those years ago (Gen. 27). Could the events of the night before have had something to do with this dramatic change of heart? Jewish interpreters [1] certainly think so, in some cases viewing Jacob’s wrestling partner to be ‘the ministering angel of Esau.’ Before Jacob is ready to meet Esau in the flesh, he has to undergo a spiritual confrontation. There are multiple ways to approach this text. One way is to explore it from a psychological angle. Thus, Jacob is seen to be wrestling with his personal history, anxieties, guilt. The blessing he grasps is the blessing of having endured a crisis, of having confronted his inner demons and matured in the process. In this view, Jacob emerges a new person: free from fear, at peace with himself and those around him. Esau senses this, it disarms him, and reconciliation is possible. Does this interpretation speak to you? Was there a time when you wrestled amidst crisis, ‘alone’, ‘in the night’ and came through a stronger, wiser, more mature person? There is another current in Jewish interpretation: one that relates Jacob’s ordeal to the struggle of the Jewish people in coming to terms with the fact of their election by God. After all, wouldn’t it be easier to fit in with society; to not be identified by circumcision, Shabbat or dietary practices? It would certainly have saved centuries of persecution, sorrow. Yet struggle is part of fidelity. To live the Torah means to strive for the ways of God; not settling for moral mediocrity nor despairing of the possibility of a transformed earth. Yes, it entails wounds that at times produce a limp. But it also holds the priceless blessing and responsibility of belonging to God and God's people. Certainly, Jacob’s story draws us to be attentive to the fact that throughout their history the Jewish people have had to struggle against extraordinary odds, and have prevailed, time and again, to grasp anew the irrevocable blessing of their identity. (These words are not intended to romanticise the idea of fidelity through struggle, which has entailed a terrible cost to Jewish lives.) Amid the political complexities of our own time, there are those who are quick to judge the Jewish people on account of certain government policies of the modern state of Israel, rather than making appropriate distinctions between the two. Yet “Israel”,[2] whether understood as a nation state or as a covenantal people, produces plenty of its own critics and prophets from within, and this too forms part of its struggle for self-determination. It is important for Christians to ponder the biblical moment in the book of Genesis when God’s choice of Abraham finds new expression in and through Jacob's struggle. It is vital for understanding Judaism, Jesus and Christians' own call to ‘be’ church—not replacing God’s covenant with the Jewish people which endures eternally, but rather learning from its truth. As St Pope John Paul II said on his visit to Sydney (26 November 1986): “For the Jewish people themselves, Catholics should have not only respect but also great fraternal love; for it is the teaching of both the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures that the Jews are beloved of God who has called them with an irrevocable calling.” • 1. Sources: Herczeg, ed., The Torah: With Rashi’s Commentary (New York, 1999); Leibowitz, New Studies in Bereshit (New York, 1994); Plaut, The Torah: A Modern Commentary (New York, 2006); Sacks, Covenant & Conversation (Jerusalem, 2009). Scripture: NJPS. 2. The term "Israel" has multiple meanings. It can refer to the biblical land; the name given to the patriarch Jacob or to one of the twelve tribes issuing from his progeny; the political nation state named Israel (either in its ancient or modern context). “Israel” is also a theological reference to the Jewish people, from their origins in history to their ultimate destiny in accord with God’s designs. © Teresa Pirola, 2011. lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Download the PDF version . Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry based in the Catholic community in Australia, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. The reflection above refers to Parashat Vayishlach (Genesis 32:4 - 36:43), the Torah portion read for this Sabbath in the Jewish liturgical cycle. Shabbat shalom ! Download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, courtesy of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- 6 December: Anniversary of Aboriginal leader's protest against the Nazis
On this day, 6 December 2024, the anniversary of William Cooper's courageous protest in the wake of Kristallnacht in 1938, and as a synagogue is burnt to the ground in Melbourne overnight, we are urged to take 5 minutes to listen to a short video message from Professor Marcia Langton AO. (Courtesy National Council of Jewish Women Australia) Professor Langton describes the relationship between Jewish and First Nations people in Australia and warns against the exploitation of the First Nations cause and flag by activists who undermine that important relationship and who feed the antisemitic forces at work in our country. Background note: On 6 December 1938, just weeks after Kristallnacht (the Nazi-sponsored pogrom that targeted Jews in Europe, where synagogues and Torah scrolls went up in flames, and many Jews were killed or deported) an inspirational Aboriginal leader in Melbourne, William Cooper, led a march to the German consulate in Melbourne to protest the, "cruel persecution of the Jewish people by the Nazi government in Germany" ( Learn more .) His actions had no impact on Hitler's regime. Yet, he did the right thing. He spoke up, and helped others to do the same. William Cooper, a Yorta Yorta man and a Christian, continues to inspire First Nations people, Christians and all people of faith and goodwill to be vocal and active in standing in solidarity with Jewish communities as antisemitism surges in Australia and around the world.
- Jacob's Ladder: A message of comfort and reassurance
Our Torah reflection this week, from Chapter 28 of Genesis, opens with Jacob, the grandson of Abraham, fleeing to Haran having just deceived his father and his brother and caused a great upset in the family. In Haran he will fall in love, marry and start his own family; but for now he is on a solo journey. Our discussion today will focus on Jacob’s dream of a heavenly staircase or ladder. It has a powerful impact on him. Read the story in Genesis 28:10-22. “And he dreamed that there was a ladder set up on the earth, the top of it reaching to heaven; and the angels of God were ascending and descending on it” (28:12). In traditional Jewish methods of biblical interpretation, attention to every detail of the text, including the order of words, is paramount. Did you notice what might have caught the attention of the sages in the above passage? Why, they wondered, does the Torah say that the angels ascended before saying that they descended . If angels of God come from heaven, wouldn’t we expect the text to say that they descended the ladder first, then ascended afterwards? With a prayerful imagination, ponder this question as you re-read these verses and those around it. Some rabbinic commentaries view the angels in highly symbolic terms. A different and intriguing explanation, however, is offered by Rashi, the esteemed 11th century Jewish Torah scholar. According to Rashi’s explanation (which echoes the midrash), the angels of God have specific assignments. Those that operate in the Land of Israel do not leave that area. So when Jacob departed from his homeland and headed for Haran, these angels ascended to heaven first and other angels then descended to escort him outside the Land of Israel. Perhaps our 21st century western minds register some discomfort with Rashi’s explanation! But remember that our task here is to uncover spiritual meaning in the text and to appreciate the wisdom of the great tradition. In this light, surely Rashi’s explanation offers a profound insight into the constancy of God’s protection. Wherever our life’s journey takes us—into new geographical areas, new experiences, new challenges—God sends us help, and not just ‘any’ help, but assistance personally tailored to our unique circumstances; and not only from angelic messengers, but from special people who enter our lives at critical moments and show us the way forward with their loving care and guidance. It is a comforting thought, and one based in our faith in God’s providence, that as our lives change, divine assistance is attentively moving with us from beginning to end. Many Christians find this in their own funeral rite where the congregation prays for the deceased: "May the angels lead you into paradise..." • Reflection : Share an experience of God’s protection and care during your life. Name special people who have been part of that memory, that journey. Bibliography: Leibowitz, New Studies in Bereshit (New York: Lambda, npd); Plaut, The Torah: A Modern Commentary (New York, 2006); Schermann & Zlotowitz, eds., Rashi: Commentary on the Torah (New York, 1999). Scripture: NRSV. © Teresa Pirola, 2013. lightoftorah.net . Reproduction for non-commercial use permitted with acknowledgement of website. Download the PDF version . Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Vayetze (Genesis 28:10 - 32:3), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. As our year of Torah reading proceeds, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- Rebecca's Prayer
"She went to inquire of the L ORD , and the L ORD answered her…" (Gen 25:22-23, JPS). Pregnant with two sons who are already warring within her womb, Rebecca goes "to inquire of the Lord", regarding her distressing pregnancy. There is something about her inquiry that catches our attention and causes us to pause, to question and to ‘dig deeper’ into the sacred text. In one sense Rebecca's inquiry is consistent with her story and personality; and yet there is something else about it that appears inconsistent or odd. Can you pick it? (Read the verse in the context of 25:19-26, and bring to bear your wider knowledge of Genesis, too.) First, the consistency. Rebecca approaches the Lord in a manner that is direct, confident and forthright. She is not a timid woman. This fits with the initial picture we have of her, when Abraham’s servant first encounters her at the well in Chapter 24. There, Rebecca is physically and socially proactive, reaching out hospitably and moving “quickly” (24:18,20) to draw water for her visitor and his camels. Likewise, she seems spiritually proactive, not hesitating to go directly to God, seeking answers with regard to her difficult pregnancy. And the inconsistency? This arises when we read the verse immediately prior to her inquiry: "Isaac pleaded with the Lord on behalf of his wife, because she was barren; and the Lord responded to his plea, and his wife Rebekah conceived" (Genesis 25:21). Why did Rebecca not approach the Lord directly when she was in the distressing situation of not being able to conceive? Why did Rebecca not approach the Lord directly when she was in the distressing situation of not being able to conceive? Instead, we are told that it was Isaac who approached the Lord "on behalf of his wife" (suggesting that she was present at the time). Why did Rebecca not pray herself? Especially about something of such direct and intimate concern to herself? Think about this question. Ponder the sacred text (Genesis 25:19-26), before reading on. One reply could be to argue that in fact Rebecca was praying along with Isaac. After all, the text does not specify that she did not plead with the Lord; it simply doesn't say that she did. Still, we are left with the question: why is Isaac the only one mentioned here? Step back two verses, and a clue can be found in verse 19: "This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham. Abraham begot Isaac" (Genesis 25:19) The Jewish sages are quick to point out what appears to be a superfluous repetition. We are told that Isaac is the son of Abraham, so why the addition of "Abraham begot Isaac"? Such repetition in the text is always a signal to delve more deeply, according to Jewish interpretative methods. Notice the sequence here: the emphasis on Abraham’s paternity in relation to Isaac (v.19), followed by reference to Isaac's marriage to Rebecca (v.20), followed by Isaac pleading with the Lord that his wife might conceive (v.21). It makes sense when we remember that the story of Genesis is not simply about a human family, but a family called to live in a special relationship, a "covenant", with God, as God's promise to Abraham extends to his descendants, from parent to child. Verses 19-21 highlight this, through the emphasis on Abraham begetting Isaac (v.19), through the expectation raised as Isaac takes Rebecca as his wife (v.20), and then by depicting Isaac's concern that God's blessing continue through his own offspring, hence his ardent prayer ('pleading' with the Lord) that his wife will conceive and bear a child (v.21). In this light, we can hear Rebecca's exclamation ("Why do I exist?") and her subsequent inquiry to God (v.22) as the next step in the sequence of covenantal concerns. Rebecca is aware of her own active role in ensuring that God's covenant is maintained. She is a pregnant woman experiencing pain, yes, but she is also a woman who is searching out the depths of her vocation, having married into this extraordinary family, called by the Creator of the universe to bear God's name to the world, so as to be a blessing for all the families of the earth. Note how the Lord acknowledges her awareness by answering in terms of the future relations between her two sons, "two nations", whose lives will profoundly impact the world into which they are born. What can we take from all this? Many angles are possible, but perhaps one insight is the appreciation of our own capacity to be history-makers and meaning-makers, especially through the task of bringing children into the world. Think about it: Each time a child is conceived and born, the world is never quite the same again. Something shifts forever, certainly in the lives of the child's parents and siblings, but also in humanity's story, so enmeshed is each of us in a web of social relations. Every newborn child alters history, simply by being born! History shifts, too, in view of the immense possibilities that lie ahead for a newborn child, the potential to leave their mark on the world. In this sense, every parent is profoundly engaged in history and meaning-making. Today’s Torah portion draws us to reflect on these deeply human vocational realities. In a special way, it can speak to those parents who are conscious of being part of a people in covenant with God. In partnership with God, they are aware of shaping not only history, but salvation history. Continue to ponder this story in Genesis. Bring your own reflections and questions to the Torah discussion, with close attention to the scripture text. In what way does God's word speak to you, when you hear that Rebecca "went to inquire of the L ORD "? *** Bibliography: Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Andrea L. Weiss, eds., The Torah. A Women’s Commentary (New York: URJ Press and WRJ, 2008); The JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society, 1989); Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation (Maggid Books and The Orthodox Union, 2009); Scripture: JPS © Teresa Pirola, 2024. lightoftorah.net . Reproduction for non-commercial use permitted with acknowledgement of website. Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Toledot (Genesis 25:19 - 28:9), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. As our year of Torah reading proceeds, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- Interfaith Dialogue gathering 2-4 Feb 2025 | Melbourne
If you are in reach of Melbourne this February 2025, I encourage you to register now for a three-day Gathering of people from Australia and New Zealand who are engaged and interested in interfaith dialogue and encounter. HEADS, HEARTS AND HANDS. What can Dialogue do for us? 2-4 February 2025 (Sunday to Tuesday) Melbourne Organised by the Australian Council of Christians and Jews (ACCJ), at a time when the social cohesion of societies are under great strain, participants will have a unique opportunity to hear from local and international speakers providing diverse perspectives on the nature of dialogue and the current challenges facing Christian-Jewish dialogue. There will be opportunities for conversation, reflection and participation in practical workshops. The gathering will have an international flavour to it, with a delegation of members from the board of the International Council of Christians and Jews (ICCJ) joining in, including keynote speaker Rabbi Dr David Fox Sandmel. While all are welcome, this is a particularly graced opportunity for people who have done the hard yards of interfaith engagement over the years to come together in person, to share time together, prayerful reflection and honest discussion, seeking concrete steps forward. Of course, new faces will be warmly welcomed and young people are especially encouraged to sign up. Please bring this event to the attention of your friends, colleagues and networks. To find out more, visit the ACCJ website and register at Humanitix . This is a rare and important opportunity to gather, engage and go forth with constructive ideas and tools in the critical work of building harmonious communities of respect and inclusion. Sign up now! See you there, 2-4 February 2025.
- Did Abraham marry Hagar?
" Now Isaac was coming from the approach to Be’er-lachai-ro’i" (Genesis 24:62). In Torah studies we are taught to be alert to deeper meanings whenever the sacred text mentions a particular geographical place. With the help of Rabbi Jonathan Sacks [1] , let’s explore the mention of Be’er-lachai-ro’i here in the scene where Isaac sets eyes on his wife Rebecca for the first time. What does Be’er-lachai-ro’i mean, and where have we encountered it before? "Well of the Living One of my seeing" is one translation. [2] It draws from the words of Hagar, the Egyptian slave-servant who, in an earlier story (Genesis 16), runs away from home, pregnant with Abraham’s first son. She is fleeing mistreatment at the hand of Abraham’s wife, Sarah (called Sarai at that time), and it is in the wilderness that Hagar encounters a divine messenger, the angel of the L ORD . In Genesis 16:13-14, we learn that the place of this encounter is named after Hagar’s words to the angel of the L ORD , ‘You are El Ro’i (‘the One who looks upon me’). The angel has just declared that Hagar’s child will be called Ishmael and Hagar will have descendants “too numerous to count” (16.10). Note the similar wording to God’s promise made to Abraham. Hagar then returns home, only to be expelled again by Sarah, this time in a permanent exile with her son Ishmael, or so it seems. (You can read these stories about Hagar in chapters 16 and 21 of Genesis). But, back to our original question: why would Be’er-lachai-ro’i be mentioned in Genesis 24:62, years later, as the adult Isaac comes to greet his wife, Rebecca? The Torah doesn’t tell us, but in the Midrash (the creative storytelling traditions of Judaism) the sages say that Isaac has come from Be’er-lachai-ro’i having been on a quest to track down Hagar so that she may become the wife of Abraham, now that Sarah has died (23:2). Thus, while Abraham was directing a matchmaking effort on his son’s Isaac’s behalf, it seems that Isaac was doing some matchmaking for his father! Were Isaac’s efforts successful? The Torah tells us that the name of Abraham’s second wife was Keturah; however, it is not uncommon for biblical characters to have more than one name. Also, we find out later (25:9) that both sons , Isaac and Ishmael, were involved in burying their father Abraham. Ishmael’s sudden appearance at Abraham’s grave is surprising. Unless… What if Abraham’s second wife was actually Hagar? Hence the sages’ interpretation in support of this scenario. Observes Rabbi Sacks, “This indeed integrates Abraham’s second marriage as an essential component of the narrative. Hagar did not end her days as an outcast. She returned, at Isaac’s prompting and with Abraham’s consent, to be the wife of her former master.” [3] This is indeed, a humanly poignant and ethically powerful interpretation, especially in light of the earlier domestic tensions, where Sarah declares: “The son of this slave girl is not going to share in the inheritance with my son Isaac!” (Genesis 21:10). Now, within this rabbinic perspective, we see the adult Isaac expressing, not antagonism towards Hagar, mother of Ishmael, but rather a desire to bring her back into the family fold. Despite being banished by Sarah, it seems that Hagar and Ishmael were always important to Abraham (cf. 21:11) and held a place in his heart. Isaac is the son through which God's promise to Abraham continues; however the 'outsider', Ishmael, is also valued and blessed; and ultimately the two sons are reunited. This interpretation holds out profound hope for the possibility of reconciliation in situations which were, or are, filled with conflict and division. Recall that all three Abrahamic faiths, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, look to Abraham as a foundational figure, albeit through differing interpretative lenses. Pondering the subtleties and ‘hidden meanings’ in the story of Abraham, can we find hope for all our complex relations: within homes, nations and the wider human family? Delve into these fascinating biblical stories and continue the Torah conversation. Notes: [1] Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation (Maggid Books and The Orthodox Union, 2009), 141-144. [2] See translation by Chaim Stern in Eskenazi and Weiss, eds., The Torah. A Women’s Commentary (New York: URJ Press and WRJ, 2008), 74. [3] Sacks, Covenant & Conversation , 143. Bibliography: Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation (Maggid Books and The Orthodox Union, 2009): Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Andrea L. Weiss, eds., The Torah. A Women’s Commentary (New York: URJ Press and WRJ, 2008); Scripture: translation by Rabbi Chaim Stern in Eskenazi and Weiss, eds., The Torah: A Women’s Commentary (2008). © Teresa Pirola, 2024. lightoftorah.net . Reproduction for non-commercial use permitted with acknowledgement of website. Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Chayei Sarah (Genesis 23:1-25:18), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. As our year of Torah reading proceeds, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- So, why did the Lord visit Abraham?
“The Lord appeared to him [Abraham] by the terebinths of Mamre; he was sitting at the entrance of the tent as the day grew hot” (Genesis 18:1). Just one verse into this Bible story (Genesis 18:1-15) and the Jewish sages of old were already probing and puzzling over the text. What do you think caught their attention? 'The day grew hot.’ Why would this apparently irrelevant detail be mentioned? Look closely. . . The Lord 'appeared’ (v.1), yet there is no indication that the Lord appears to say or do anything special as is the usual case (e.g., “The Lord appeared and said to so-and-so...”). Nor is Abraham doing anything special to warrant a divine appearance. He is not calling out to God or offering a sacrifice. He is just, well... sitting. Then there is the ambiguous use of pronouns: ‘he,’ ‘him.’ Although 18:1 is the opening of a new chapter, it reads as if it is continuing a previous story. And what is the preceding story? The account of Abraham’s circumcision. In fact, one rabbinic view regards the divine appearance as the grand conclusion to the story of Abraham’s circumcision, rather than the opener to the hospitality story which follows. There are, of course other rabbinic interpretations, but let’s stay with this one and follow it a little further. Ask yourself: why would God be showing up, now, at this moment, if there is no divine command to be issued, no blessing to give, no message to be delivered? Rashi (11th c. Torah commentator), echoing other voices in the tradition, teaches that on this occasion God visits Abraham, not for the purpose of an important declaration or commissioning, but simply out of personal concern. For, having just been circumcised, Abraham is physically recuperating: R’Chama the son of Chanina said: It was the third day since his circumcision, and the Holy One, Blessed be He, came and inquired about [Abraham’s] welfare. Of course, this explanation is not meant to be taken literally, yet what a tender, imaginative portrayal of God’s personal compassion and care for a faithful man. Sometimes this interpretation is used to affirm the importance of visiting the sick, for this is what God did for Abraham. So then, this divine appearance, unlike so many others recorded in the Torah, is not a means to an end, but is given for its own sake; much like friends who get together, not always to accomplish a practical purpose, but simply for the pleasure and comfort of being in each others’ presence. The text tells us “The day grew hot” (18:1). Rashi teaches that God even “bought the sun out of its sheath” so that Abraham would not be troubled by guests, because no one travels during the hottest part of the day. But then, seeing that Abraham was lonely for company, he “brought the angels to him in the form of men.” One story from the midrash (Jewish storytelling traditions) suggests that Abraham was not only physically aggrieved by his circumcision but also experiencing emotional turmoil over the thought that the sign of the covenant might lead to his isolation. “Now that I am circumcised, perhaps [travellers] will no longer visit me?” [Genesis Rabbah 48,9]. To this, God offers reassurance through a divine visitation! As much as these imaginative interpretations make us smile, they also stimulate our minds and refresh our spirit with penetrating insight and wisdom. We might ask: Has God ever ‘appeared’ to me when I was physically/emotionally/spiritually vulnerable? How might Rashi’s interpretation of Genesis 18:1 enrich the way I live my life? • *** Bibliography: Freedman and Simon, eds., Midrash Rabbah: Genesis (London, 1983); Herczeg, ed., Rashi: The Torah with Rashi’s Commentary , Sapirstein ed. (New York, 1999); Leibowitz, Studies in Bereshit (New York, 1994); Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia, 1989). © Teresa Pirola, 2012. www.lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Download the PDF version . Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Vayeira (Genesis 18:1-22:24), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. As our year of Torah reading proceeds, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- So, why did the Lord visit Abraham?
“The Lord appeared to him [Abraham] by the terebinths of Mamre; he was sitting at the entrance of the tent as the day grew hot” (Genesis 18:1). Just one verse into this Bible story (Genesis 18:1-15) and the Jewish sages of old were already probing and puzzling over the text. What do you think caught their attention? 'The day grew hot.’ Why would this apparently irrelevant detail be mentioned? Look closely. . . The Lord 'appeared’ (v.1), yet there is no indication that the Lord appears to say or do anything special as is the usual case (e.g., “The Lord appeared and said to so-and-so...”). Nor is Abraham doing anything special to warrant a divine appearance. He is not calling out to God or offering a sacrifice. He is just, well... sitting. Then there is the ambiguous use of pronouns: ‘he,’ ‘him.’ Although 18:1 is the opening of a new chapter, it reads as if it is continuing a previous story. And what is the preceding story? The account of Abraham’s circumcision. In fact, one rabbinic view regards the divine appearance as the grand conclusion to the story of Abraham’s circumcision, rather than the opener to the hospitality story which follows. There are, of course other rabbinic interpretations, but let’s stay with this one and follow it a little further. Ask yourself: why would God be showing up, now, at this moment, if there is no divine command to be issued, no blessing to give, no message to be delivered? Rashi (11th c. Torah commentator), echoing other voices in the tradition, teaches that on this occasion God visits Abraham, not for the purpose of an important declaration or commissioning, but simply out of personal concern. For, having just been circumcised, Abraham is physically recuperating: R’Chama the son of Chanina said: It was the third day since his circumcision, and the Holy One, Blessed be He, came and inquired about [Abraham’s] welfare. Of course, this explanation is not meant to be taken literally, yet what a tender, imaginative portrayal of God’s personal compassion and care for a faithful man. Sometimes this interpretation is used to affirm the importance of visiting the sick, for this is what God did for Abraham. So then, this divine appearance, unlike so many others recorded in the Torah, is not a means to an end, but is given for its own sake; much like friends who get together, not always to accomplish a practical purpose, but simply for the pleasure and comfort of being in each others’ presence. The text tells us “The day grew hot” (18:1). Rashi teaches that God even “bought the sun out of its sheath” so that Abraham would not be troubled by guests, because no one travels during the hottest part of the day. But then, seeing that Abraham was lonely for company, he “brought the angels to him in the form of men.” One story from the midrash (Jewish storytelling traditions) suggests that Abraham was not only physically aggrieved by his circumcision but also experiencing emotional turmoil over the thought that the sign of the covenant might lead to his isolation. “Now that I am circumcised, perhaps [travellers] will no longer visit me?” [Genesis Rabbah 48,9]. To this, God offers reassurance through a divine visitation! As much as these imaginative interpretations make us smile, they also stimulate our minds and refresh our spirit with penetrating insight and wisdom. We might ask: Has God ever ‘appeared’ to me when I was physically/emotionally/spiritually vulnerable? How might Rashi’s interpretation of Genesis 18:1 enrich the way I live my life? • *** Bibliography: Freedman and Simon, eds., Midrash Rabbah: Genesis (London, 1983); Herczeg, ed., Rashi: The Torah with Rashi’s Commentary , Sapirstein ed. (New York, 1999); Leibowitz, Studies in Bereshit (New York, 1994); Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia, 1989). © Teresa Pirola, 2012. www.lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Download the PDF version . Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Vayeira (Genesis 18:1-22:24), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. As our year of Torah reading proceeds, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- Go Forth! Give Life!
Now the Lord said to Abram, ‘Go from your country and your kindred and your father’s house to the land that I will show you. I will make of you a great nation, and I will bless you…and in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed. (Genesis 12:1-3) ‘Lech lecha!’ (‘Go forth!’). God’s call to Avram triggers an extraordinary adventure for Abraham and Sarah and their descendants, and for us too. As I ponder this briefest of Hebrew phrases - Lech Lecha - in the context of the first five books of the bible (Pentateuch), I am struck by its inherent call to life. I submit that, in the language of Torah, to ‘go forth’ is another way of saying, ‘Go, give life!’ The gift and giving of life – both physical and spiritual – is a recurrent theme in the bible. It leaps from the page of the Genesis creation account, as a formless darkness comes to light and life, as ‘plants yielding seeds’ and living creatures ‘of every kind’ abound, and as the first man and woman are told to ‘be fruitful and multiply’. At the other end of the story, in the Book of Deuteronomy, Moses stands on the edge of the promised land and exhorts his listeners to ‘Choose life!’ And lest we mistake this for a ‘wellbeing’ slogan, Scripture spells out its context and meaning: covenant, sacred ancestry, gift and responsibility: Choose life so that you and your descendants may live, loving the Lord your God, obeying him, and holding fast to him; for that means life to you and length of days, so that you may live in the land that the Lord swore to give to your ancestors, to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob. Choose life so that you and your descendants will live.(Deuteronomy 30:19-20) From start to finish, God’s word is a call to go ‘beyond’ oneself and to bring forth ‘more’. Thus, Genesis is the story of the birth of a people - of sexual unions and pregnancies, of births and child-rearing, of homemaking and breadwinning, of the joys and challenges of what it means to be a family called into the service of God, so that ' all the families of the earth shall be blessed.’ It is not an easy story. Giving life never is. Time and again, Scripture tells of barren women, childless couples, difficult pregnancies, warring siblings, families displaced, livelihoods threatened. And yet, still, life goes on, God’s promise finds a way. Nowhere in the Hebrew Scriptures is this paradox more obvious than in the story of Abraham and Sarah, called to bring forth countless descendants, yet childless until their old age. Their story continues to inspire our own efforts and struggles to ‘give life’. Like Abraham and Sarah, we are sent forth into the fray of earthly complexities, with all its difficulties and deaths. It is precisely here that the call is to be life-givers, to bear witness to God’s light, life and presence in the world. Whether we are physically bringing forth children and grandchildren, or being generative in myriad other ways, when we hear ‘lech lecha’ our response is to live and love as fully as possible, using all our God-given gifts and opportunities to be a blessing, to leave the world, not simply as we found it, but with ‘more’ than it was before we arrived. The journey to ‘go forth’, ‘to a land that I will show you’ might, literally, entail a geographical land – a home in a new country or the same neighbourhood in which we grew up. It will most certainly refer to a mental, spiritual and ethical landscape. Whatever the 'land' to which one goes forth, the call entails courage, persistence, growth, change, the painful mistakes of maturing and the challenge to boldly and lovingly contribute to one's family, community and surrounds. As with Abraham and Sarah, the journey will not be smooth, easy or always successful. It is a journey that we entrust to God, knowing that others have travelled this way before us. We are in good company, with Abraham and Sarah and with the whole people of God on a pilgrim path. Enough said.... Lech lecha! Scripture: NRSVACE Image: Shutterstock © Teresa Pirola, 2024 www.lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Lech Lecha (Genesis 12:1 - 17:27), the Torah portion read this week in the annual Jewish liturgical cycle. Shabbat shalom. Download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .
- The Tower of Babel
With an eye to the Jewish cycle of readings, this week we open the Book of Genesis and ponder the story of the Tower of Babel (11:1-9). This ancient story is a telling about the human family and is set prior to the particular calling of Abraham which appears a chapter later. It is a story with echoes in other ancient cultures. Archaeological evidence points to the remains of a form of tower (ziggurat) which was once a feature of ancient Mesopotamian cities, along with inscriptions similar to the words in Genesis, “Come, let us build ourselves a city, and a tower with its top in the heavens, and let us make a name for ourselves…” (Gen 11:4). In Jewish tradition, the Tower of Babel is largely interpreted as a symbol of the arrogance of human beings, to think that they can build their way up to heaven, as if the Almighty is in reach and can be grasped - indeed, conquered and controlled - by human effort. Such folly is laid bare as God disables the builders’ plans by confusing their speech and dispersing them, and their languages, across 'the whole earth' ( kol ha-aretz - a Hebrew phrase which occurs five times in just nine verses). In the writings of Rabbi Jonathan Sacks (1) we find this theme explored within the framework of a key word found in the first creation story of Genesis, with the Hebrew root b-d-l , which means to distinguish, separate, divide. In the creation story, God divides light from darkness, waters from dry ground, and distinguishes between the various life forms, including animals from human beings. Finally, God separates the sacred (the Sabbath day of rest) from the secular (the six days of work). It is this fundamental distinction and separation in the order of the divinely willed cosmos that allows human beings to exist harmoniously with their Creator and with one another. The builders of the tower can be seen to subvert that order by attempting to collapse the distinction between heaven and earth, between the Creator and those who are created. The result of their overreach is the destruction of their grandiose plans to 'make a name' for themselves.(3) Thus, a critical lesson for societies and civilisations is carried forward through the Scriptures of Israel. Writes Sacks, “Only a respect for the integrity of creation stops human beings from destroying themselves. Humility in the presence of divine order is our last, best safeguard against [hu]mankind arrogating to itself power without constraint...” (3) It strikes me that another way to express this same wisdom is within the framework of the Sabbath. One of the great practical gifts and safety nets that Judaism has brought the world is the reminder that, amidst lives so often filled with frenetic activity in the name of progress, innovation and development, we need to pause periodically to simply rest in the knowledge that God , not you or me, is the Creator and ultimately in charge of the universe. This is the genius of honouring the Sabbath as 'a day apart'. The practice of Sabbath rest, one day in seven, keeps in view the fact that, while human beings have the incredible privilege of being co-creators with God, we are not God. All that is godly about us we owe to the Creator who has fashioned us in the divine image, who draws us into relationship and continually breathes life into our very existence. We are called to be in a proactive, lively partnership (covenant) with God, yes, but not to try to dominate the partnership. The risk of blurring the line is part of negotiating our way through life, and life is a dangerous project! We should not shy away from the adventure or avoid necessary risks; but that is why we need to keep hearing the ancient story of the Tower of Babel, preserved and interpreted by Jewish tradition, and by Christianity too, as a symbol and reminder of what is at stake. Enjoy reading the nine verses of the Tower Babel (Genesis 11:1-9). Consider the dangers of 'tower-building' in your own life and community. Reflect on the gift of the Sabbath day in light of this Torah portion. Join the Torah discussion. Notes: Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis (New Milford, CT: Maggid, 2009), 49-55. In a fascinating wordplay, the Tower of Babel story uses two Hebrew words with the same root letters but in reverse order to indicate the reversal of the builders' misguided plans: 'brick' and 'confuse'. Sacks, Covenant & Conversation , 55. Bibliography: Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Andrea L. Weiss, Eds, The Torah. A Women’s Commentary (New York, 2008); Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis . A Book of Beginnings (New Milford, CT: Maggid Books, 2009); Scripture: NRSV. Image: Tower of Babel, painting by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1563. [Shutterstock] © Teresa Pirola, 2024. lightoftorah.net . Reproduction for non-commercial use permitted with acknowledgement of website. Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry initiated within the Catholic community in Australia, encouraging Christians to reflect on the Hebrew Scriptures with the help of insights from traditional Jewish approaches to the sacred text. The reflection above refers to Parasha Noach (Genesis 6:9 - 11:32), the Torah portion for this Sabbath in the Jewish liturgical cycle (in the diaspora). Shabbat shalom.
- Beginnings
A new idea has extraordinary power. It can be embraced, rejected, or ignored, but what one cannot do is ‘unthink’ it. So says creative thinker Edward De Bono, and so ‘says’ the first creation account in the opening chapters of Genesis (1:1-2:4). For what do we find here but the quintessential innovative idea, uttered as God’s creative word, that brings into being the universe and sets it upon its dramatic course of cosmic productivity. Human beings can embrace it, reject it, or (try to) ignore it, but what they cannot do is ‘uncreate’ it! We are part of a history set in motion by God who is intimately involved in, yet utterly free of, the world and ridiculously optimistic in our regard. Genesis 1 invites us to reflect upon this radical innovation and optimism that grounds our very being. There is the challenge of over-familiarity with this text. We have heard the creation story so often, from childhood bible stories to parish Easter vigils. But the invitation is to listen again and, more than listen, to speak it out loud and hear it from each other’s lips. And when we do, what do we hear? With the help of the translation of Everett Fox, what can be heard in a fresh way is the text’s methodical rhythm. Fox points out that the closer one gets to the Hebrew text and the sensuality of the Hebrew language, the more obvious this is. (In the NRSV, too, if we read slowly and deliberately, the rhythmic structure can be appreciated.) God said: Let there be light! And there was light. God saw the light: that it was good. God separated the light from the darkness. God called the light: Day! and the darkness he called: Night! [Fox] What is interesting here? Certainly the repetition of ‘God-plus-verb’. But what is strange about it? The austere language and plodding sound-pattern makes it all seem so orderly, effortless. God says , God sees , God separates , God calls … and it is so! Surely the creation of the world cannot be that easy! But here lies the power of the text’s structure to communicate its central message. God is portrayed as being totally in control of, and at peace with, the creative process. There is gradual ascent, but no urgency; nothing is forced. God gets there, when God is ready (Fox, 10; Plaut, 19). Yet there is a paradox. There is methodical rhythm and sense of careful order, yes. But on the other hand, as our Torah text unfolds, it bursts at the seams with imagery that is anything but calm and restrained: unwieldy growth spurts, lifegiving abundance, joyful abandon. As a wind ( ruah ) from God sweeps over the waters, a dark, formless void comes to life. Subtle repetitions underscore the fertility of the emerging scene; for example: “Let the earth put forth vegetation: plants yielding seed… fruit trees of every kind….that bear fruit with the seed in it” (v.11). Then again, waters bring forth not just living creatures but “swarms” of them (v. 20). The earth itself is created to [re]create; to bring forth, having been brought forth. Plurality and diversity are inscribed in the act of creation, as indicated by the repeated phrase (nine times) ‘of every kind’. Wild animals, sea monsters, and all those ‘creepy-crawly’ things (I wonder why that term “creep/creeping” is mentioned five times) find a home in water or soil. On Day Five, living creatures are judged to be ‘good’, blessed, and commanded to reproduce. On the sixth day, human beings are created, elevated, blessed, entrusted with responsibility, called ‘exceedingly good’ and told to reproduce. And as if that isn’t enough, behind the creation story Jewish tradition abounds with even more creation stories. In brief, one of them goes like this: God consults with Torah before creating the world. When Torah expresses her scepticism as to whether the world can survive human sinfulness, God assures her that human goodness will indeed prevail. After all, God has already created repentance….[1] God is not only creative, but decisive and optimistic in the act of creating! Then, in the final verse of our text, we hear: “These are the toledot of the heavens and the earth: their being created” (Gen. 2:4). Literally, toledot means ‘generations’ or ‘births’. Some translations render it ‘story’; Plaut, ‘chronicles’. In the NRSV it is ‘generations’, and in Fox’s translation, ‘begettings’. Genesis will continue to unfold with generational stories—stories of sexual unions, pregnancies and births… longed-for ones, difficult ones, successful ones. But the overarching theme of generational fecundity and continuity starts right here ‘at the beginning’ (Gen.1:1). It sets the tone for the entire story of Israel. The God of Israel is the One who brings forth LIFE. We hear it also in the voices of the prophets. At all times, even in its most grievous chapters of exile, Israel is called to trust in “the One who created the heavens…, who made the earth… who gives breath to its people” (Isa. 42:5). God’s covenant with Israel is inseparable from God’s creative act. Created as we are in the divine image, we too are equipped with extraordinary lifegiving power. How terrifying! There is so much that dampens our creative spark: rejection, failure, the slavery of unbridled work schedules. Little wonder that people pull their heads in, saying, “I’m not the creative type.” Some are afraid to have a child. The story of our beginnings calls us not to be afraid But the story of our beginnings calls us not to be afraid; to believe that, embedded in our very existence, is a desire to burst forth, spill over, share, and extend the very life force, natural and spiritual, that pulses within us. Isn’t that what 2 Timothy is getting at - " God’s gift was not a spirit of timidity...” (1:7) - and the kind of confidence the Gospel of Luke has in mind with reference to the power of faith to uproot a tree and plant it in the sea (see Lk. 17:6)? Our creative efforts are not to be obsessions, but work embraced in freedom, in love. For unlike other gods, Elohim (the Hebrew name for God used in the first creation account) creates with ease, not struggle; calmly sets the sun and the moon as if hanging lanterns, resisted by no creature. Here our Torah text can be seen as Israel’s critique of surrounding cultures [Fox, 12; Plaut, 20]). Most importantly, Elohim sets limits to the creative labor and sanctifies Sabbath rest which becomes “the first sign of revelation within the act of creation itself”.[2] The picture is of a completely sovereign Creator in whom we can have total trust. To be human, then, is to have confidence in one’s innovative powers, but in a relaxed way, trusting in a divinely creative source beyond self. • For Reflection and Discussion: God is my Creator. Ponder this intimate relationship. Think of one aspect of your God-given creativity that has been dimmed by hurt, cynicism, sin. How does God want to ‘recreate’ that part of you? Take steps that will help the healing process. 1. Ginzberg, Legends of the Jews. 2. Rosenzweig, The Star of Redemption , quoted by Fritz, 'Sabbath Rest and Sunday Worship', T he Way Supplement (2000/97). Bibliography: Fox, The Five Books of Moses (New York, 1995); Fritz, ‘Sabbath Rest and Sunday Worship’, The Way Supplement (2000/97); Ginzberg, The Legends of the Jews, (1909; www.sacred-texts.com/jud/loj/index.htm); HarperCollins Study Bible: NRSV (London, 1993); Plaut, The Torah: A Modern Commentary (New York, 2006). © Teresa Pirola, 2012. www.lightoftorah.net This article may be reproduced for non-commercial use with acknowledgement of website. Download the PDF version . Light of Torah is a grassroots ministry, encouraging Christians to reflect on Torah with the help of Jewish insights. More... The reflection above refers to Parashat Bereshit (Genesis 1:1 - 6:8), the first Torah portion read as the annual Jewish liturgical cycle begins again. As we begin a new year of Torah, download your free Jewish and Christian Liturgical Calendar, thanks to the generosity of Etz Hayim-Tree of Life Publishing .










